Assessment of the Educational Benefits of a Feral Cat Management Program in
the Professional Veterinary Curriculum
Dawn M. Fradkin and Margaret R. Slater, DVM, PhD
Departments of Veterinary Anatomy and Public Health and Small Animal Medicine and Surgery
Texas A&M University, College Station, Texas 77843-4458
Abstract Presentation
Merck Research Fellowship Conference
University of California, Davis
Saturday, August 12, 2000
The issues of pet overpopulation should be of utmost importance in the
veterinary profession. Estimates of the number of stray and feral cats in the
United States range from 10 million to over 50 million, with 5 to 7 million cats
euthanized in animal shelters annually. As veterinarians, we must educate our
clients on matters of responsible pet ownership, and facilitate humane animal
population control. A thorough knowledge of feral cat behavior, control, and
management is essential if we are to counsel our clients on matters of pet
overpopulation control and management.
Since August of 1998, the College of Veterinary Medicine at Texas A&M University
and the Aggie Feral Cat Alliance of Texas (AFCAT) have humanely trapped and
neutered feral cats on campus. This TNR (trap/neuter/return) program identifies
and adopts out socialized adult cats and kittens, and unadoptable/unsocialized
adult cats are returned to their trap site after neutering and released. Returned
cats are maintained in managed colonies where they are fed and supervised by
caregivers on a regular basis. AFCAT volunteers trap and oversee management of
cats on University property, and, with the assistance of private funding, the
College of Veterinary Medicine subsidizes feral cat gonadectomies and routine
healthcare as part of the 4th year educational experience. Our study was designed
to evaluate the educational benefits of the inclusion of the feral cat management
program into the 4th year curriculum by examining the attitudes and practices of
individuals related to feral cat management and pet overpopulation following
graduation.
A survey with 36 questions, 118 possible responses, and a comment section was
sent to graduates from the TAMU Veterinary class of 1999. An identical survey
was sent to the Veterinary class of 1999 at the University of Tennessee, which
is located in a similar climate, but has no feral cat management in the curriculum
or on the campus. The overall response rate was 71%, with a 73% response from
TAMU (90/124) and a 68% response from UTN (38/56). No statistically significant
differences in response rate, age, gender, practice type or location were found
between the two classes. One Canadian territory and 28 U.S. states were represented.
Approximately 90% of respondents work in practices where feral cats may be
treated, 68% in small animal practice and 22% in small/large animal mixed practice.
Nearly two-thirds of respondents (64%) report that they see feral cats in practice.
Experience with feral cats as described by 77% of respondents includes client-owned
(31%), AFCAT program (19%), other TNR participation (23%), animal shelter/control
(8%), other (7%). Given the high potential and actual demand for veterinary
treatment of feral cats, it is evident that veterinary students require training
in this area.
Summary statistics were analyzed by frequency distribution, continuous data
was analyzed using Wilcoxon rank-sum tests and categorical data was analyzed
using Chi Square association tests for heterogeneity or independence. Statistically
significant differences [p < 0.05] are indicated by asterix (*).
| |
|
TAMU |
UTN |
|
Have heard of TNR before |
* |
96% |
74% |
|
Have experience w/ feral cats |
* |
83% |
63% |
|
Aware of feral colonies in area |
|
39% |
35% |
|
Aware of TNR program in area |
|
24% |
22% |
|
See feral cats in practice |
|
64% |
64% |
|
Would participate in TNR program |
|
76% |
71% |
|
Would promote TNR program |
|
47% |
34% |
|
Would offer discounted feral cat services |
|
45% |
45% |
|
Would offer volunteer feral cat services |
|
40% |
45% |
|
Would donate supplies to treat feral cats |
|
15% |
13% |
|
Do not support TNR management programs |
|
7% |
13% |
|
Not willing to treat ferals at all |
|
7% |
8% |
|
Not willing to participate in community TNR |
|
16% |
16% |
|
Reservations about TNR due to risk to owned pets |
|
23% |
37% |
|
Reservations about TNR due to liability |
* |
18% |
40% |
|
Reservations about TNR due to risk of self injury |
* |
37% |
63% |
|
Lack equipment to promote/participate in TNR |
* |
4% |
21% |
|
Lack training to promote/participate in TNR |
* |
4% |
29% |
|
Participated in feral cat lab before graduation |
* |
50% |
3% |
|
# of surgeries performed before graduation was adequate |
* |
59% |
34% |
The mean number of student surgeries performed at each school was not
statistically different; however, descriptive evaluation indicated a large
disparity in the range of surgeries per student at UTN (1-400 vs. 7-125 at TAMU).
Further investigation revealed that this disparity was due to variable
participation in Remote Area Medical field trips offered at UTN. Additional
surgeries created by a TNR program at UTN could enhance the student surgical
experience. Currently only 34% of UTN graduates feel that the number of surgeries
they performed prior to graduation was adequate, compared to 59% at Texas A&M.
Interestingly, a similar percentage of UTN graduates see feral cats in practice
compared to Texas graduates, further indicating that inclusion of a feral cat
management program in the UTN veterinary curriculum could be beneficial. Texas
A&M students who participated in (or were exposed to) feral cat TNR were less
likely to have reservations about TNR, had better awareness of feral cat management
practices, had more experience with feral cats, and were more comfortable with
the amount of surgical training they received.
Return to AFCAT Home Page
This page was last updated on: October 23, 2003
Copyright 2000 Texas A&M University College of Veterinary Medicine
Report technical problems to the
Webmaster.
[Contact CVM]
[CVM Home]
[Privacy Statement]
[Search]
[Site Map]
[Texas A&M Home Page]
|